In
Chicago's whitebread Northwest Side and close-in
suburbs, the specter of raising taxes is viewed as
a cultural issue, not a fiscal issue.
Most
area residents have an us-versus-them attitude --
the "haves" against the "have nots."
They believe that there is an inverse relationship
between the payers and the payees, and that those
who pay more in taxes get less in government
services, while those who pay less in taxes get
more in benefits. They are utterly devoid of
liberal guilt, which is normally expiated by
spending more on the so-called disadvantaged.
On
the Northwest Side, woe to the hapless politician
who votes for a serious tax hike. It's a betrayal
of trust, of class, and of region. It's a one-way
ticket to oblivion. The May 31 vote in the
Illinois House of Representatives is illustrative
of area politicians' visceral fear of being
labeled a "tax hiker."
Proposed
by Governor Pat Quinn, Senate Bill 2252 sought to
raise the state income tax from 3.0 percent to 4.5
percent on individuals, and to 7.2 percent on
corporations. The measure lost 74-42, with two
"present" votes; 26 Democrats joined all
48 Republicans in opposition. Customarily,
Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan dictates how
every Democrat votes. Not on this bill. Survival
dictated how the Democrats voted, and every
Northwest Sider -- John D'Amico (D-15), Joe Lyons
(D-19), Deb Mell (D-40) and John Fritchey (D-11)
-- joined the anti-tax majority.
Lyons,
D'Amico and Fritchey were unopposed in both the
primary and the election in 2008; Mell was
unopposed in the primary, and she won the election
with 74.9 percent of the vote. But they all had
the tax-hike jitters.
"It's
like pointing a loaded gun at my head and inviting
somebody to pull the trigger," said one area
legislator. "I'm not going to risk doing
it."
Also
opposing the increase were Mike McAuliffe (R-20)
of Chicago, Beth Coulson (R-17) of Glenview, Skip
Saviano (R-77) of Elmwood Park and Rosemary
Mulligan (R-65) of Des Plaines.
The
only area incumbents supporting the bill were Toni
Berrios (D-39), from a heavily Puerto Rican Logan
Square district, where her father, Joe Berrios is
the Democratic committeeman, and Lou Lang (D-16)
of Skokie, a longtime liberal who will face no
wrath from his largely Jewish constituency, which
is crammed with do-gooders. Both were unopposed in
the primary and the election in 2008.
Other
north suburban Democrats, all liberals, backed the
tax hike: Julie Hamos (D-18) of Evanston, Elaine
Nekritz (D-57) of Northbrook and Kathy Ryg (D-59)
of Vernon Hills. So did Lakefront Chicagoans Sara
Feigenholtz (D-12), Greg Harris (D-13) and Harry
Osterman (D-14). All were unopposed in the 2008
primary, and Hamos, Harris and Feigenholtz were
unopposed in the election. Osterman won reelection
with 85.5 percent of the vote, Nekritz with 67.9
percent and Ryg with 63.7 percent.
Coulson
and Hamos are running for Congress in the 10th
District.
As
if to validate the Northwest Sides' stereotypical
perception, all seven Hispanics and all but two
(who voted "present") of the 18 black
Democrats embraced the Quinn hike.
Rejecting
media hype about the "necessity and
urgency" of an income tax hike, and about how
"vital services" would otherwise suffer,
11 suburban and Collar County Democrats and two
Southwest Side Chicago Democrats opposed the tax
hike. Clearly, on the Northwest Side, suburbanites
from less liberal areas did not want to put
themselves in the crosshairs.
Had
Madigan made Senate Bill 2252 into a "Save
Illinois" crusade and brought a majority (60)
of Democrats on board by promising them oodles of
2010 campaign cash, the bill would have passed.
But 26 Democrats feared voter reprisals, viewed
2010 as an anti-tax year, and refused to venture
into harm's way.
The
adjoining vote chart
displays the votes of area representatives. Here's
a look at their 2010 prospects:
D'Amico,
age 47, is part of the 39th Ward's "Laurino
Machine." His aunt, Marge Laurino, is the
alderman, and his late grandfather, Tony Laurino,
was the former alderman. His parents were
convicted as ghost payrollers, and he still double
dips as a deputy district superintendent in the
city Department of Water Management. His first
contest was in 2004, when he won the primary with
59 percent of the vote and the election with 66.9
percent. He was unopposed in 2006 and 2008.
Avoiding the tax-hike rap, D'Amico is safe.
Lyons,
age 58, is the cousin of the late 45th Ward
Democratic committeeman Tom Lyons, and he has
served since 1996. He is the president of the ward
Democratic organization. He also is part of the
Madigan leadership as one of seven assistant
majority leaders. Lyons won the 2004 primary with
70.1 percent of the vote and the election with
77.8 percent. He was unopposed in 2006 and 2008.
He is strong as onions, but he didn't want to be a
"tax hiker."
Fritchey,
age 45, embarrassed himself mightily by losing the
special 5th U.S. House District primary on March
3, getting just 9,815 votes (17.8 percent of the
votes cast). He began the campaign as the
favorite, but he lost to Mike Quigley. Fritchey is
the 32nd Ward (Wicker Park-area) Democratic
committeeman, and he has been a state
representative since 1996, when he replaced Rod
Blagojevich. He is married to the daughter of Sam
Banks, the brother of outgoing 36th Ward Alderman
Bill Banks. Fritchey wisely voted against the tax
increase. He was poised to run for state attorney
general in 2010 had Lisa Madigan retired.
With
his credibility now in tatters and his statewide
path blocked, Fritchey is bailing out of
Springfield to run for Cook County commissioner in
2010, seeking the open seat of Forrest Claypool.
He has been endorsed by Claypool and Quigley.
Fritchey is young enough and smart enough to
rehabilitate himself as a county
"reformer" and run for mayor or Cook
County Board president in the future.
Berrios,
age 32, and Mell, age 41, may not, like
astronauts, have the "right stuff," but
they do have the right DNA. Their fathers could
pass for Daddy Warbucks, and, at the risk of being
sexist, they're in Springfield because they're
daddy's little girls. (There also are some daddy's
little boys.)
Joe
Berrios made his daughter a state representative
in 2002, at age 25, and she has never faced
opposition. The elder Berrios, a Board of Review
commissioner, is running for county assessor in
2010; he has $846,883 in his campaign fund. When
Joe Berrios becomes assessor, expect him to give
his daughter his powerful Board of Review job.
Alderman
Dick Mell (33rd) made his son-in-law Rod
Blagojevich a state representative, a congressman
and the governor. When Deb Mell decided she had a
mission, the elder Mell ousted longtime incumbent
Rich Bradley to make room for her in 2008. Here's
some advice for the alderman: Learn how to
"just say no." Count on this: When Mell,
age 70, retires from the City Council, his
daughter will want the job. Guess what Dick will
say?
Lang,
age 59, is one of the Cassandras of Illinois
politics, perpetually pondering a run for
statewide office but never pulling the trigger.
It's too late to run for treasurer or comptroller
in 2010, as the fields have formed. But Lang is an
assistant majority leader, and he aspires to be
the speaker when Madigan retires. When Lang votes
for a tax hike, he's pandering to the minorities
and liberals in the House Democratic Caucus in a
vote on the next speaker. First appointed in 1987,
Lang is safe.
McAuliffe,
age 46, has served since 1996, when he replaced
his late father, Roger, who had held the post
since 1973. He can't be termed a "daddy's
boy," since it was his father's organization
that elevated him, and he faced -- and prevailed
-- over fierce Democratic opposition, winning with
52.4 percent of the vote in 1996, 53.7 percent in
2002 and 59.4 percent in 2008. McAuliffe knows to
"just say no" to any tax-hike bills. He
can't be beat.