Like
the title of the Stanley Kubrick movie, Democrat
Mark Dobrzycki's campaign for state representative
in the Northwest Side 20th District can be
characterized as "Eyes Wide Shut."
Dobrzycki, a Harwood Heights trustee, hasn't a
clue as to how to win or why he'll lose.
After
defeating two Democratic powerhouses -- state
Representative Bob Bugielski in 2002 by 2,583
votes (with 53.7 percent of the votes cast) and
state Representative Ralph Capparelli in 2004 by
7,773 votes (59.2 percent) -- incumbent Republican
Mike McAuliffe (R-20) surely deems Dobrzycki's
challenge a mere nuisance, akin to Tiger Woods
playing miniature golf after winning the U.S.
Open.
Dobrzycki
lacks money, manpower, name identification and the
visible support of key Democrats in the district,
most notably state Senator Jim DeLeo (D-10) and
36th Ward Alderman Bill Banks, who also is the
Democratic committeeman. McAuliffe boasts all of
the above, including the behind-the-scenes support
of DeLeo and Banks. Dobrzycki's only hope is for a
Democratic "wave" in November which
drowns all Republicans.
"It's
time for a change," insisted Dobrzycki, age
44, who was elected a trustee in 2003 and who
plans to run for re-election in 2007 and again for
the Illinois House in 2008 if he is not successful
this year. "The McAuliffes have been in
office too long," he said, referring to Roger
McAuliffe being state representative from 1972
until his death in 1996 and his son Mike holding
the seat since.
Of
course, Dobrzycki ignores the fact that Democrat
Mike Madigan has been the Illinois House speaker
for 22 of the past 24 years and a state
representative for 36 years. And the fact that
Capparelli, when he lost to McAuliffe in 2004, had
been in Springfield for 34 years. And the fact
that Democrats have held a majority in the
Illinois House for 28 of the past 32 years and
that they currently have a 65-53 majority. And the
fact that Democrats control the state Senate and
House and the governorship.
In
fact, should Dobrzycki defeat McAuliffe, the only
"change" would be the substitution of a
junior, powerless, irrelevant newcomer for a
go-along, nonconfrontational 10-year Republican
incumbent for whom local and Springfield Democrats
have no particular animosity.
With
the election just 2 months away, there's no way
that McAuliffe can lose. Here's why:
First,
Dobrzycki has yet to launch his campaign. He has
no campaign office, no campaign staff, no campaign
literature, no campaign money, and only a vague
campaign plan. He admits that he is getting no
assistance from Madigan and no support from Banks,
DeLeo or Capparelli, who is still the 41st Ward
Democratic committeeman. Only Norwood Park
Township Democratic Committeeman Bob Martwick is
helping him.
McAuliffe,
age 42, is a chronic campaigner, a veritable
"Eveready Bunny." In past races he
walked precincts from May through November. His
office keeps track of his contacts, follows up on
problems or requests, gets a commitment for a yard
sign, and locks in the vote. McAuliffe is
especially strong in the 41st Ward, where his
ally, Brian Doherty, is the alderman. McAuliffe
has replicated that strategy again in 2006, and he
has been out walking while Dobrzycki has been
doing nothing.
Second,
Dobrzycki has no money. The latest state board
filings indicate that his committee has raised
$16,917. McAuliffe had $15,765 on hand on July 1.
In 2004 McAuliffe raised $600,890 and spent
$580,825. Capparelli, who chose not to seek
re-election in the 15th District, spent $288,073.
In 2002, after Madigan created a district for
Capparelli, who then ran elsewhere to open the
seat Bugielski, McAuliffe spent $470,296, to
Bugielski's $411,821. McAuliffe will get plenty of
money from Springfield Republican sources if he
needs it. Without Madigan's financial help,
Dobrzycki is going nowhere.
And
third, without a personal precinct organization,
Dobrzycki must rely on the committeemen to
generate a big vote in the 36th and 41st wards. He
will be disappointed. In 2002 Bugielski, backed by
Banks and DeLeo, won the 36th Ward with 61.1
percent of the vote but lost the 41st Ward, where
McAuliffe got 62.5 percent. In 2004 McAuliffe won
the 36th Ward with 56.1 percent of the vote and
the 41st with 63.3 percent.
McAuliffe
could not have won Banks' ward without Bank's
support. He will have it again in 2006. And in the
41st Ward, Capparelli's organization is
practically nonexistent. To win, Dobrzycki needs
60 percent of the vote in both the 36th Ward and
Norwood Park Township and must hold McAuliffe
under 60 percent in the 41st Ward. That just won't
happen.
Dobrzycki
expects to use his ethnicity to his advantage.
Born in America, he is the son of Polish
immigrants. Dobrzycki noted that half the voters
in Harwood Heights, 45 percent of the voters in
Norridge and a third of the voters in the 36th
Ward are of Polish ancestry. "I have a
database," Dobrzycki said. "I will
target them with mailings. They will support
me." He also claimed that his "life
experience" better qualifies him for the job.
"I am a family man, and can better relate to
the needs of families in my district," he
said, a slap at the fact that McAuliffe is
unmarried. My prediction: McAuliffe will win
easily.
Speaking
of "change," Chicago home owners will
get socked with a huge change in their property
tax bills next year if the General Assembly
doesn't extend the 7 percent cap on property
assessment increases, which expires this year, in
the fall veto session. As detailed in the
adjoining vote chart, all the area representatives
voted for an extension of the cap until 2010, but
the bill was defeated 69-37.
McAuliffe,
and Republicans in general, are trying to make
that a major campaign issue. Without the cap, tax
bills will increase substantially next year.
"This will especially impact senior
citizens," McAuliffe said. "People are
worried." The vote rejecting the cap was
based on geography, not party. Downstaters and
suburbanites of both parties opposed it, not
wanting to be viewed as pro-Chicago.
So
where is Mike Madigan when we need him? The
speaker is legendary for his iron control of his
House troops. Madigan raises enormous sums of
money and doles it out to needy legislators. He
dictates to the Democratic Caucus members how they
will vote, and the legislators, if they want
Madigan's campaign cash in the future, comply.
Included
in the vote chart
are eight other state representatives, including
Chicago Democrats John Fritchey (D-11), Rich
Bradley (D-40), John D'Amico (D-15), Joe Lyons
(D-19) and Larry McKeon (D-13) and suburbanites
Lou Lang (D-16) of Skokie, Elizabeth Coulson
(R-17) of Glenview and Rosemary Mulligan (R-65) of
Des Plaines.
McKeon,
the House's only openly gay member, will resign
later this year due to health problems. He
represents a North Lakeview district, and Gregory
Harris, the chief of staff of Alderman Mary Ann
Smith (48th), who also is openly gay, has been
chosen as his replacement.
All
incumbents are safe except Coulson, who was absent
on numerous end-of-session votes due to her
mother's illness. She narrowly defeated Skokie
trustee Michele Bromberg in 2004 by 28,422-24,315,
getting 53.9 percent of the vote and spending
$474,299 to Bromberg's $452,039. Madigan targeted
that race, and he poured in money and sent staff
to aid Bromberg. Her 2006 Democratic foe is
21-year Skokie trustee Judith Rae Ross, who,
unlike Dobrzycki, will have plenty of help from
Madigan. She could win.