Odd
as it may seem, the public's distress over the
situation in Iraq appears to be having an adverse
effect on Governor Rod Blagojevich's popularity.
With
unceasing strife, death and confusion in Baghdad,
voters in Illinois are now markedly less tolerant
of unceasing strife, political bickering and
budgetary confusion in Springfield.
A
mid-May poll by the Chicago Tribune put
Blagojevich's job approval rating at just 40
percent; that's way down from his 55 percent in
February. The governor's campaign fund reportedly
spends $1,000 a day on polling, and he can trot
out poll results at any time, but he has yet to
release any polling that disputes the Tribune's
numbers. Blagojevich used to proclaim that he was
America's most popular governor. That idiotic
refrain is no longer trumpeted.
Blagojevich's
problem is that he envisions himself as the next
Bill Clinton, who was a creature of his pollsters
and who mastered the technique of constantly
pitting himself against others. Clinton would poll
to find a popular issue, proclaim his support for
it, attack those who were against it, hold some
press conferences and photo ops, buttress his
image as a "fighter," and then forget it
and move on to the next issue. With a Republican
Congress through most of his term, Clinton did not
attempt to govern through conciliation and
compromise. Instead, his game plan was to engender
conflict and blame others for lack of results, but
to quickly take credit for any accomplishments.
That's
been Blagojevich's strategy. Orchestrated by chief
of staff Lon Monk and deputy governor Brad Tusk,
Blagojevich has spent the last 17 months
bolstering his image as a fighter. He generates
headlines when he defies Mayor Rich Daley or
Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan, or when he
proclaims that he's against raising income taxes
or granting a casino license to Chicago -- and
that he's "keeping his promises."
To
be sure, Blagojevich is great as a candidate and
great as a campaigner. But as a governor, he has
been a great flop. Mayor Richard J. Daley once
observed that good government is good politics.
What Blagojevich has failed to grasp is that a
governor is supposed to govern, and not just
campaign.
One
of the most popular governors in America is
California's Arnold Schwarzenegger. Like
Blagojevich, Schwarzenegger promised that he
wouldn't raise taxes. Like Illinois, California
faced a huge budget shortfall. The current
Illinois budget is $53 billion, and the projected
revenue shortfall for fiscal year 2005 is $2.3
billion; the current California budget is $99
billion, and the projected 2005 revenue shortfall
is between $12 and $24 billion. Like Blagojevich,
Schwarzenegger used borrowing and spending
deferments to close a $38 billion shortfall in
2004. But, unlike Blagojevich, Schwarzenegger --
who has a Democratic legislature -- used
conciliation and compromise to achieve his goal.
He did not attack or criticize the Democrats, but
he made it clear that he would blame them if they
failed to work with him to solve the fiscal
problem.
One
of the most popular governors of Illinois was Jim
Thompson. For 12 of his 14 years, the Democrats
controlled the General Assembly. Like Blagojevich,
Thompson was a perpetual campaign machine, forever
traipsing around the state. He never governed like
a conservative, and the state budget increased
from $10 billion to $26 billion. His spending on
roads and capital projects created jobs, patronage
and goodwill among Springfield politicians.
Thompson was a competent governor, but too liberal
to get the Republican presidential nomination.
Blagojevich
clearly aspires to be president, and he is
relentlessly positioning himself as the populistic
champion of the common people against the
"special interests." The governor's
target is 2008. However, if Democrat John Kerry
wins the presidency in 2004, then Blagojevich's
timetable will be pushed back to 2012 or later.
Blagojevich
is not on Kerry's short list of vice-presidential
picks for 2004, and he's on the non-list of future
presidential picks among Springfield and City Hall
insiders. In his brief tenure as governor,
Blagojevich has alienated the state's Democratic
establishment. Of course, both Daley and Madigan
may be retired when Blagojevich runs for the White
House, but, in order to run for president,
Blagojevich must either (1) still be governor and
have compiled a credible, popular record, or (2)
have retired as governor (not having been
defeated) and have the solid backing of Illinois'
Democrats. At present, both those options look
remote.
The
2006 election is far away, so Blagojevich can
repair some of his political wounds. But, to date,
he has made three huge mistakes:
Mistake
Number One: He estranged himself from the guy who
put him on the track to be governor: Alderman Dick
Mell (33rd), his father-in-law. Mell repeatedly
assured his fellow ward committeemen and aldermen
that the spigot of state patronage would open and
flow freely if Blagojevich won. It hasn't. There
are virtually no state jobs flowing to Chicago
ward organizations.
George
Ryan, during his last year as governor, engineered
the passage of an early-retirement bill that
prompted 11,000 state employees to retire. That
was supposed to cost the state $622 million; it is
now projected to cost $2.45 billion. And now
Blagojevich proposes cutting the state's workforce
of 64,000 by 3.6 percent (2,300 jobs). Most of the
vacant positions are unfilled. "All he is is
mouth, mouth, mouth," Alderman William
Beavers (7th) reportedly said. "He's a one-termer."
Mistake
Number Two: He estranged himself from Daley,
saying that his "vision for Illinois"
would not allow a city-owned casino. Such a casino
allegedly would generate $300 million in annual
revenue for Chicago and $700 million for the
state. "It's too easy," said the
governor of Daley's plan, which he promised to
veto if it passed the legislature. "The world
doesn't work that way."
Message
to Governor Rod: The world does work that way.
Voters crave simple, easy solutions to difficult
problems. The 2005 state budget has a $2.3 billion
hole, and a casino, which could be operational
within a year, would help close it. To be sure,
Blagojevich looks tough standing up to the mayor.
But Daley will remember, and reap his revenge
later.
Mistake
Number Three: He has estranged himself from the
Democratic majority in the General Assembly,
especially Madigan. The Democrats have not had
control of the governorship and the state Senate
and House since 1975-76. It was expected that they
would work together to pass their agenda, but the
governor repeatedly emphasizes that he will fight
the "old way" and that his priority is
to "reform" state government.
Madigan,
who has been speaker for 20 of the past 22 years,
is accustomed to quietly cutting deals with
Republican governors. He's not accustomed to being
pilloried as an ogre by a rookie Democratic
governor. Madigan proposed a "zero
growth" 2005 budget, which Blagojevich
promptly rejected, calling it a "do
nothing" budget. The governor's budget
contains roughly $400 million in new school
funding and $600 million in new Medicaid funding;
he also proposed $400 million in new business
taxes and threatened to lay off 6,000 state
employees if the tax hikes weren't approved. The
governor also wants to tap $1.7 billion from
various state funds to close the revenue deficit.
Then
Attorney General Lisa Madigan, the speaker's
daughter, issued a legal opinion that a 20-year,
$216 million mortgage on the Thompson Center,
which was approved by the legislature, is
unconstitutional. It was not approved by a
three-fifths majority, as is required for all
long-term state debt. That further increased the
state's revenue shortfall.
Blagojevich
then attacked Lisa Madigan, saying that "it's
her father" who precipitated the ruling. A
furious rebuttal ensued, with one female state
senator calling him a "Neanderthal," and
state Treasurer Judy Baar Topinka calling him an
"incompetent governor" who is
"nothing more than a male chauvinist
pig."
If
no budget is passed by July 1, or if Blagojevich
vetoes a "zero growth" budget, then
state government could be shut down. In pondering
his decision, the governor should remember this:
First,
the economy is rebounding, so the state's revenue
projections will be higher in 2006 and 2007.
And
second, the electorate is increasingly inclined to
want competent and conciliatory leaders. That
means that politicians who are fighters, blamers
and shirkers are less and less palatable.
If
Blagojevich doesn't quickly get in step with the
"old way," he will be out of the way in
2006, after one term as governor.