Platitudes
do not necessarily presage performance. In 2008
Barack Obama ran as a reformer who would bring
change. Instead, he has governed as a typical
tax-and-spend liberal Democrat.
The
proper platitudes do, however, presage victory,
especially in a Cook County Democratic primary
where minorities and liberals predominate. As
proven by Toni Preckwinkle's sizable Feb. 2
victory for Cook County Board president, such buzz
words as "independent,"
"reformer" and "competent"
have great impact, particularly when the
incumbent, Todd Stroger, is perceived as the
incompetent tax-hiking nonreformer.
In
analyzing the outcome, here are a few appropriate
journalistic platitudes:
*Everybody
hates Todd. Stroger's demise eclipses mere defeat
or rejection, surpasses embarrassment or
humiliation, and approaches abasement and sheer
mortification. The incumbent board president got
13.6 percent of the vote. That's an astounding
personal repudiation, based on voter anger and
abject loathing.
Stroger
won four of 50 Chicago wards and got a mere 41.3
percent of the vote in his home 8th Ward. He took
17.1 percent of the Chicago vote and just 8.6
percent of the suburban vote. As for his 78,532
voters, there are counselors available to provide
trauma therapy, either for their remorse in
backing him or for their shock in being so stupid.
"The
Toddler's" misguided, misgoverned 4-year
reign is proof positive that there is no gene for
political astuteness, and further proof that in
the fall election, tax hikers are doomed.
*Preckwinkle
is another Obama. Preckwinkle, a 19-year black
Chicago alderman who rarely dissented from the
City Council majority of Mayor Rich Daley and who
has no governing experience, rode a tide of
anti-tax, anti-Stroger sentiment and won
countywide with 50 percent of the vote. She
amassed 281,905 votes, to 131,896 (23.0 percent)
for Terry O'Brien, 83,150 (14.4 percent) for
Dorothy Brown and 78,532 (13.6 percent) for
Stroger. Turnout was 575,483.
Derided
by some as the "white liberal" candidate
and by others as the "Daley stealth"
candidate, Preckwinkle, age 62, assembled an
Obama-like coalition of blacks, Hispanics and
Lakefront and suburban white liberals while
running exceedingly well in white ethnic wards and
townships.
According
to official tallies, Preckwinkle won 34 of 50
wards, getting 47 percent of the Chicago ballots.
She won six of eight Hispanic-majority wards, 14
of 20 black-majority wards and all six Lakefront
wards.
Preckwinkle
also won 24 of 30 suburban townships, racking up
70 percent or more of the vote in Barrington,
Evanston, New Trier, Northfield and Oak Park
townships. She got more than half the vote in
white-majority Elk Grove, Hanover, Lyons, Maine,
Niles, Palatine, Rich, River Forest, Riverside,
Schaumburg and Wheeling townships.
In
2004, when Obama ran for the U.S. Senate, he got
301,199 votes, or 66.5 percent of the vote, in
Chicago and 163,718 (60.8 percent) in the suburbs.
He ran exceedingly well in white liberal areas,
and he got 25 to 35 percent of the vote in white
ethnic wards. The difference: Obama got
near-unanimous black support, and Preckwinkle got
only 40 percent support from black voters.
*Liberals
love Toni. In the Lakefront wards, which cast
43,187 votes, Preckwinkle got 29,944 votes, or
69.3 percent of the vote, to 7,052 (16.3 percent)
for O'Brien and 2,391 (5.5 percent) for Stroger.
She also had huge margins in suburban liberal
enclaves Evanston (77.9 percent of the vote) and
Oak Park (73.8 percent).
*More
black voters supported the electable black
candidate than the racially pandering black
candidate.
Stroger
ran on the premise that the 1-cent sales tax hike
was needed to provide health services to
minorities. That was a racist appeal. However,
many black voters understood that, with three
black candidates running, O'Brien would win if
they did not coalesce behind a single candidate.
In effect, a vote for Stroger or Brown, the clerk
of the Circuit Court, was a vote for O'Brien.
Turnout
in the 20 black wards was 142,493. Preckwinkle got
57,892 votes, or 40.6 percent of the vote,
carrying 12 of 14 South Side wards. Stroger got
43,430 votes (30.4 percent), winning the 8th,
21st, 24th and 34th wards, while Brown got 33,645
votes (23.6 percent), winning the 29th and 37th
wards.
In
the suburbs, Preckwinkle won the black-majority
townships of Bloom, Bremen, Calumet, Proviso and
Rich, getting 53.4 percent of the total suburban
vote to 8.6 percent for Stroger and 11.7 percent
for Brown.
Representing
the South Lakefront Hyde Park area, where Obama
resides, Preckwinkle is an intellectual, not a
streetwise black activist, but her goal was to get
40 percent of the black vote, and at least half of
that number came from black voters who wanted to
keep an African American in the board presidency.
*The
Daley/Madigan/Burke/Lipinski/Hynes machine did not
fare well. Or did it? O'Brien, the 14-year
president of the Metropolitan Water Reclamation
District Board of Commissioners, is a longtime
Daley ally with ties to the South Side. But he ran
an insipid campaign, failing to establish himself
as the principal alternative to Stroger. He
promised to rescind the hated sales tax hike but
not to cut additional taxes or spending.
To
win, O'Brien needed to be a demagogue. He needed
to make a vote for him a vote against Stroger. He
needed to make promises that appealed to white
middle class voters. He didn't, and getting an
anemic 23.0 percent of the countywide vote means
his future political prospects are nil.
O'Brien
did, however, carry 10 city wards and six
townships. He won the mayor's 11th Ward with 51.2
percent of the vote, Ed Burke's 14th Ward with
53.5 percent, Mike Madigan's 13th Ward with 42.1
percent, Bill Lipinski's 23rd Ward with 54.4
percent and Tom Hynes' 19th Ward with 46.3
percent. But even in those wards Preckwinkle ran
well, getting 36.3 percent of the vote in the
11th, 27.0 percent in the 14th, 36.1 percent in
the 13th, 36.4 percent in the 19th and 31.8
percent in the 23rd Ward.
Pre-primary
rumors abounded that Daley really wanted a black
board president going into the 2011 mayoral
election so as to minimize black discontent. If
so, he got his wish. If Daley wanted O'Brien to
win, he would have gotten 70 percent of the vote
in those wards.
*Adios.
As in the 2008 Obama-McCain election, Chicago-area
Hispanic voters showed no hesitation in supporting
a black candidate (Preckwinkle) over Stroger. In
the eight Hispanic-majority wards, which cast
30,826 votes, Preckwinkle got 13,795 votes, or
44.7 percent of the vote, to 9,127 (29.6 percent)
for O'Brien and 2,207 (7.1 percent) for Stroger.
However, O'Brien won suburban Cicero Township
(with 45.7 percent of the vote) and Stickney
Township (with 56.7 percent).
As
with white ethnic voters, Hispanic voters clearly
wanted to be rid of Stroger, and Preckwinkle was
the best instrument.
*White
voters will vote for the least objectionable black
candidate, especially if it means ousting the most
objectionable black candidate. On the Northwest
Side, where O'Brien, as the sole white candidate,
was presumed to have appeal, he carried only three
wards: the 45th Ward, where O'Brien got 47.8
percent of the vote (3,827 votes), to 43.5 percent
for Preckwinkle; the 36th Ward, where he got 45.9
percent (3,341 votes), to 38.6 percent for
Preckwinkle; and the 41st Ward, where he got 51.9
percent (5,030 votes), to Preckwinkle's 41.6
percent. Preckwinkle won the 32nd Ward with 66.3
percent of the vote, the 33rd Ward (55.5 percent),
the 38th Ward (49.4 percent), the 39th Ward (49.8
percent), the 40th Ward (56.9 percent), the 47th
Ward (67.5 percent) and the 50th Ward (51.3
percent).
Why
did Preckwinkle do so well? Four reasons: First,
Stroger was deemed an abomination. He had to go.
Second, O'Brien failed to click as a candidate.
Third, Preckwinkle, by campaign's end, loomed as
the frontrunner. For voters determined to oust
Stroger, a Preckwinkle vote did the deed, while an
O'Brien vote was a waste.
And
fourth, as demonstrated in the 2004 U.S. Senate
primary and the 2008 presidential primary, which
both were won by Obama, there are substantial
numbers of independents and liberals in the area
who will vote for a non-white, non-conservative
candidate.
"She
has never voted independently of Daley, has never
implemented any reforms, and has not actually
changed anything," said Roger Keats, the
former state senator who is the Republican
candidate for board president. "I am change.
She is business as usual."
Another
platitude: You can't beat somebody -- however
vacuous -- with nobody. Preckwinkle is the midget
killer, the woman who purged Todd Stroger. To
many, she's the white knight. Keats is unknown,
and it will cost him $2 million to run a viable
campaign.
A
final platitude: Perception defines reality.
Preckwinkle is perceived as independent, competent
and a reformer. Like Obama, her platitudes may not
presage her performance, but they are enough to
enable her to win in November.