In
politics, as in many personal and commercial
endeavors and pursuits, size matters. Burger
joints urge customers to Supersize, and
convenience stores promote a Big Gulp.
For
a politician, however, the margin of victory in
one election invariably affects the degree of
difficulty to be encountered in the next election.
In short, the bigger the margin, the less the
difficulty.
For
those weary of the 2004 election, read no further.
But for those who are insatiable political
junkies, or who have idle time on their hands,
here's my final, final 2004 election analysis.
15th
Illinois House District: "Supersize Me."
That was the projected goal of 39th Ward
Democratic Committeeman Randy Barnette, the
campaign manager and chief strategist in Democrat
John D'Amico's successful campaign for state
representative in the Northwest Side district.
Barnette
sought to orchestrate a victory of such gargantuan
proportions that D'Amico, the grandson of the late
Alderman Tony Laurino and the nephew of Alderman
Marge Laurino, who is Barnette's wife, would face
no credible opposition in the future. Barnette
achieved his goal. D'Amico won a tough primary and
coasted to a solid election victory, and he now
has a lifetime seat.
The
district, which was designed in 2001 to be a
Democratic bastion by Illinois House Speaker Mike
Madigan, is centered on the 39th Ward, which
contains roughly 40 percent of the district's
vote. D'Amico beat attorney Dennis Fleming in the
primary with 59.7 percent of the vote, augmented
heavily by his showing in the 39th Ward, where he
got 69.3 percent of the vote. D'Amico's campaign
spent nearly $100,000.
In
the general election against Republican Bill
Miceli, D'Amico, a city worker who lives in
Edgebrook, got an remarkable 74.1 percent of the
vote in the 39th Ward, almost 10 percent higher
than Democratic presidential candidate John
Kerry's showing. In 2002 Democratic state
Representative Ralph Capparelli, who chose to run
in the new district, defeated Miceli by a
10,469-vote margin, with 68.1 percent of the
total. This year, as a non-incumbent, D'Amico beat
Miceli by 12,924 votes and got 66.9 percent of the
votes cast.
Both
Miceli and D'Amico live in the 39th Ward, but
D'Amico obliterated his foe. D'Amico beat Miceli
in Miceli's home precinct by 244-159 (60.5
percent), while in the precinct in which D'Amico
was raised and in which he is a longtime precinct
captain, he crushed Miceli 417-61 (87.2 percent).
For
D'Amico, age 42, the worst is over. Future
contests will focus on his voting record and
constituent service, not his heredity or family
baggage. It should be remembered that in 1995
Marge Laurino, who had been Tony Laurino's
aldermanic aide, was forced to carry the baggage
of her father, who had been indicted by the U.S.
attorney on ghost-payrolling charges. But she won
comfortably, and she was easily re-elected in 1999
and 2003.
This
year D'Amico was slammed by Fleming because both
his mother and his father had been convicted in
the ghost-payroll probe and because, as a district
foremen for the city Department of Water
Management, seven members of his crew were
suspended after it was revealed during the Chicago
Sun-Times' "Hired Truck" investigation
that they took long lunches and falsified time
sheets. D'Amico apologized for his lack of
oversight.
D'Amico
spent close to $50,000 against Miceli, and he sent
out eight districtwide direct-mail pieces, with an
emphasis on his youth, energy and family. In the
39th Ward, with 47 precincts in the 15th District,
D'Amico recruited about 150 volunteers, who
supplemented the 150 captains already assigned to
those precincts. In contrast, Miceli sent out two
mailers, both bemoaning the "culture of
corruption" in the 39th Ward, but he had no
ground game on election day. D'Amico won the
portion of the district in Chicago with 71.1
percent of the vote, and he won the suburban
portion (primarily Niles) with 59.5 percent.
Capparelli,
who ran in the adjacent 20th House District this
year and lost, resigned from his 15th District
seat in early November, and D'Amico was appointed
to his seat. In 2006 he will have a legislative
record and will have had 2 years to perform
constituent services, campaign and raise a
$150,000 campaign warchest. That, plus the size of
his 2004 victory, make the 15th District seat
solidly Democratic and secure for D'Amico.
5th
District Supreme Court contest: Democrats in
general, and trial lawyers in particular, took a
Big Gulp when Republican Lloyd Karmeier beat
Democrat Gordon Maag for a vacant state Supreme
Court seat in the Southern Illinois 5th District.
The state's high court had a 5-2 Democratic
majority, and any tort-reform legislation or
lower-court decisions not pleasing to trial
attorneys were generally deemed dead on arrival
when appealed to the court. Karmeier won with a
stunning 55 percent of the vote, and the Supreme
Court's Democratic majority and is now 4-3 -- and
that matters.
Taking
in 37 far Downstate counties and centered in the
media market around East Saint Louis, the 5th
District has long been a Democratic bastion, and
it has not elected a Republican justice since the
1940s. The Democratic incumbent, Moses Harrison,
retired in 2002. The Democrats nominated Maag, an
appellate court judge to face Karmeier, a trial
judge.
The
U.S. Chamber of Commerce, through its Institute
for Legal Reform, supplemented by Illinois
business, medical and manufacturing groups, poured
money and manpower into Karmeier's campaign, while
Madigan and trial attorney groups poured money
into Maag's. Karmeier tagged Maag as a "tool
of the trial lawyers" and highlighted the
fact that exorbitant personal injury and medical
malpractice judgments in the Madison County-Saint
Clair County region increased the cost of medical
malpractice insurance and caused many doctors to
leave the area or shutter their practice. This
issue motivated many voters to back Karmeier.
Nationally,
the chamber was involved in 13 supreme court races
in various states this year, and "tort
reform" candidates won 12 of them. In fact,
Republicans won 13 of 14 state supreme court races
where the contest was partisan.
In
2000, in the historically Republican 3rd District
(which spans the state from Kankakee to Rock
Island), well funded Democrat Tom Kilbride scored
a huge upset. Madigan sent his workers into the
area for Kilbride, and more than $800,000 was
spent on his behalf. In 2002, in the adjacent,
largely rural 4th District, centered on
Springfield, the Republican candidate barely won.
Since
Illinois Supreme Court justices serve 10-year
terms, a Republican (or tort reform) takeover will
not occur until 2010at the earliest, when
Kilbride's seat is up. If he runs for retention,
he surely will win. Cook County elects three
justices, and all are anti-tort reform Democrats.
But
the Karmeier victory sends a clear message: Tort
reform has teeth. If just one Supreme Court
Democrat defects on any key case, the trial
lawyers will be a very unhappy bunch.
However,
the chamber could adopt another tactic. Of the
seven justices, three are elected at-large in Cook
County (with a 2000 population of 5,376,741), and
the other four run in single-member Downstate
districts. That means Cook County elects 42.9
percent of the Supreme Court, and contains 43.3
percent of the state's population, which in 2000
was 12,419,293. One-person/one-vote requirements
mandate equal population in all election
districts. Therefore, it could be argued that
there should be seven single-member Supreme Court
districts, each containing 14.3 percent of the
state's population. A federal lawsuit could
challenge the constitutionality of Illinois'
system. If single-members districts were to be
drawn in Cook County, it is possible that a
tort-reform Republican could win in a suburban
district.