Alderman
Pat O'Connor (40th) heard his congressional death
knell clang loudly on Jan. 10, when 19 Northwest
Side and suburban Democratic committeemen met and
decided that they would not endorse a candidate in
the March 3 primary for the open 5th U.S. House
District seat.
And
O'Connor has nobody to blame but himself. He
committed several cardinal sins: He hesitated,
prevaricated and vacillated, and he trusted his
fellow committeemen. As a result, he got his head
handed to him on a platter.
Remember
this: These are the same committeemen who in 1996,
at the behest of Alderman Dick Mell (33rd), slated
state Representative Rod Blagojevich, Mell's
son-in-law, to be the Democratic nominee for U.S.
representative. Blagojevich was narrowly nominated
and easily elected. In 2002 these same
committeemen did their utmost to nominate him for
governor.
All
Illinoisans will surely echo this reproof: Thanks
a lot, you morons. Had you not made him a
congressman, he would not have become governor,
and he would not now be in the midst of an
impeachment.
In
2002, with the 5th District seat open, Mayor Rich
Daley decreed that area committeemen support
former Clinton White House aide Rahm Emanuel. They
did, and Emanuel won the primary with 50.5 percent
of the vote. Emanuel is now the chief of staff in
the Obama White House, and he has resigned his
congressional seat. A special election is set for
April 7, but the March 3 Democratic primary will
effectively determine the next occupant of the
seat.
O'Connor,
age 54, was first elected alderman in 1983 at the
age of 28, having supported Rich Daley in the
Washington-Byrne-Daley mayoral primary. O'Connor
is now the mayor's unofficial floor leader in the
City Council. A deft politician who harbored lofty
political ambitions, O'Connor lost the 1990
Democratic primary for state's attorney and the
1992 election for state's attorney. Had he run
again in 1996, instead of Daley crony Dick Devine,
O'Connor would have won.
When
Emanuel announced on Nov. 6 that he would follow
Obama and quit, O'Connor could have wrapped up the
job. All he needed were a few simple sentences.
First,
he needed to publicly declare: "I want the
job."
And
second, he needed to pressure Daley, his erstwhile
ally and leader, into publicly declaring: "I
want O'Connor in Congress."
Neither
utterance was forthcoming. O'Connor failed to pull
the proverbial trigger. Daley didn't intercede.
And O'Connor's fellow committeemen (some of whom
are fellow aldermen) betrayed him. After 25 years
in politics, O'Connor learned a hard lesson: You
can't trust anybody, especially when a powerful
job is at stake.
The
Democratic vote in the February 2008 primary was
125,767.
At the slatemaking session, each
committeeman cast a weighted vote equivalent to
the Democratic vote in his ward in the primary.
O'Connor got a measly 22,901 votes (18.2 percent
of the total), coming from his 40th Ward and the
adjacent 39th Ward of Committeeman Randy Barnette.
A hefty 61,529 votes were cast for state
Representative John Fritchey (D-11), just 1,355
shy of a majority. Another 41,341 votes were
undesignated. Since nobody got a majority, the
committeemen voted for an open primary in which
each ward and township organization can support
whom it chooses.
Fritchey,
unlike O'Connor, had a game plan. He wanted no
endorsement, as that would have committed each
committeeman to support the slated candidate, and
he didn't want to be endorsed, as a definite
stigma attaches to being the "bosses'
candidate." Now Fritchey's got the best of
all possible worlds: He's not endorsed, but he's
supported by all the key district ward
organizations.
Fritchey
was backed by an impressive array of committeemen,
all of whom supposedly were supporting O'Connor:
Mell, shamelessly the player, Alderman Bill Banks
(36th), whose brother is Fritchey's father-in-law,
Alderman Pat Levar (45th), Alderman Gene Schulter
(47th), whose reported deal is that he can name
Fritchey's Illinois House successor, and 38th Ward
Committeeman Patti Jo Cullerton.
But
remember this: Fritchey got Blagojevich's Illinois
House seat in 1996 as part of a deal between Mell
and Banks in which Banks backed Blagojevich for
Congress and Mell punched Fritchey's ticket to
Springfield. Now the deal is this: The "Banks
Clan" gets the congressional seat, Schulter
gets the state House seat, and O'Connor -- because
Daley didn't intervene -- gets screwed.
With
the Jan. 19 filing deadline passed, here's the
Democratic field:
*Fritchey,
age 44, has been a vociferous critic of
Blagojevich, and he sponsored a bill to limit
"pay-to-play" campaign contributions
from state contractors. He is the 32nd Ward
Democratic committeeman, but his House district
encompasses, at best, 10 percent of the
congressional district. West of California Avenue
and north of Lawrence Avenue, he is utterly
unknown. But Fritchey has two key advantages: He
has a longstanding anti-Blagojevich record, and he
is backed by the bulk of the committeemen who put
Blagojevich into office. In a low-turnout primary,
Fritchey would be the favorite. The committeeman
can deliver pluralities for Fritchey in their
wards.
*State
Representative Sara Feigenholtz (D-12), age 52,
has served in Springfield since 1995, and she
calls herself the "progressive reform"
-- meaning liberal -- candidate in the race.
Feigenholtz' district is to the east of Fritchey's,
extending along the Lakefront from Elm Street to
Lawrence, east of Racine Avenue, and taking in not
more than 5 percent of the 5th District. West of
Sheffield Avenue, Feigenholtz is utterly unknown.
But
Feigenholtz has three key advantages: First, she
has already raised $300,000, she can expect
another $250,000 from feminist Emily's List
political action committee, and she will raise
another $200,000. With a 2000 population of
654,647, the 5th District contains roughly 165,000
households, but the number of Democratic
households, given their vote of 125,000, is
roughly 40,000. If Feigenholtz spends $500,000 on
direct mail, that equals 10 pieces set to every
household during February.
Second,
she is the only woman in the race, as well as the
most liberal and the most gay-friendly candidate.
Based on gender alone, she will run a close second
in the western wards while carrying the Lakefront
wards.
Third,
she is the least conventional candidate.
*O'Connor
has filed to run anyway, but he will get no
traction. If he couldn't get slated, he surely
won't get nominated. No other committeeman will
back him. He'll be lucky to get 10 percent of the
vote -- an absolute humiliation.
*Mike
Quigley, a Cook County commissioner from the
Lakefront 10th County Board District, was first
elected in 2002. Barely 5 percent of Quigley's
district is in the 5th District, but Quigley,
along with county Commissioner Forrest Claypool,
have been persistent critics of County Board
President Todd Stroger and his policies.
"He's very well known," Claypool said.
"He's gotten a lot of media visibility on
county issues."
Of
course, Quigley's candidacy is a win-win situation
for Claypool. If Quigley goes to Washington, he
won't be a contender for County Board president in
2010, giving Claypool a clear shot at Stroger in
the primary, and if Quigley loses, his credibility
suffers. Quigley will run as a liberal reformer.
The question is: Does he drain more ideological
and geographic votes away from Feigenholtz than
non-gender (meaning male) votes from Fritchey? The
answer: Fritchey suffers more.
Eleven
other candidates filed in the Democratic primary:
Justin Oberman, Charles Wheelan, Victor Forys,
Frank Annunzio, Pete Dagher, Cary Capparelli, Tom
Geoghegan, Jan Donatelli, Roger Thompson, Paul
Bryar and Chris Monteagudo.
Here's
the early outlook:
Turnout:
Last Feb. 5 the turnout was astronomical: 125,767.
In the 2006 primary it was 64,653. Emanuel beat
Nancy Kaszak in 2002 by 11,058 votes, getting 50.5
percent of the vote in a turnout of 92,625.
Blagojevich beat Kaszak in 1996 by 7,792 votes,
getting 49.8 percent of the vote in a turnout of
68,043. Turnout on March 3 will barely eclipse
35,000. In a multi-candidate field, whoever gets
15,000 votes is the winner.
Positioning:
Given the sour, almost toxic, atmosphere suffusing
Illinois, 5th District Democratic contenders will
aggressively distance themselves from Blagojevich
and the morass of corruption in government.
Feigenholtz, in particular, has the money to hang
the "politics as usual" necklace around
Fritchey. Watch her ads: "Another
Blagojevich," she will say of Fritchey. It
will be effective.
Motivation:
Who votes? Machine committeemen in the 33rd, 36th,
38th, 39th, 45th and 47th wards ought to be able
to turn out at least 3,000 votes each for Fritchey,
but Feigenholtz will get 2,000-plus votes in each
ward. If the Quigley vote equals that of
Feigenholtz in the area east of Damen Avenue,
Fritchey wins.
The
bottom line: Fritchey needs half the vote in the
area between Damen and Cumberland Avenue and a
quarter of the vote in the eastern portion of the
district. The key will be the western suburbs, in
Leyden Township, where nobody is known. Expect a
mass invasion of Chicago precinct workers for
Fritchey. To win, Fritchey needs half of the
suburban vote.
My
early prediction: Feigenholtz' "I'm not a
corrupt Blagojevich Democrat" posture is the
right image at the right time, but it all comes
down to turnout. If it's less than 30,000,
Fritchey wins; if it's more than 40,000, it will
be a Feigenholtz upset.